vForums Support > Artwork & Design :: Graphics Discussion & Showoff :: > Signature

Signature - Posted By sliker (sliker) on 9th Jul 08 at 4:38am
Image

Re: Signature - Posted By Sven (sven) on 9th Jul 08 at 4:59am
A very annoying sig with little to no skill used to make it.

It's just a render, with a brushed/filtered background, some crappy text and an attempted border.

There isn't anything to this signature, it annoys me even.

Re: Signature - Posted By sliker (sliker) on 9th Jul 08 at 5:01am
If You Can Make Something Better
Make It or Zip it {Lips Sealed}

Re: Signature - Posted By Alex Bailey (system) on 9th Jul 08 at 9:12am
lmao, he could do a better sig than that, don't start having ago at someone because he gave you bad critique on here, isnt that what you posted it for.

Re: Signature - Posted By Sven (sven) on 9th Jul 08 at 1:02pm
I'm not going to show him up. He can be ungrateful for the comment (not that there was much substance to it) and make himself feel better by telling me that I can't make better especially when he hasn't seen my works - not that really matters. What was said was immature.

I'm not going to bring vForums down, nor my reputation by continuing this little argument that was about to boil over. Thanks for your support .System, but it's his choice to accept the criticism or to reject it, I only provide what was asked of me.

Re: Signature - Posted By Nick (nickb) on 9th Jul 08 at 4:40pm
The signature is really great, and Sven what you fail to realize, is that no one will be as good as you, nor be as bad as you. Everyone has their own style. If you don't like that persons style ok. Sure you gave him or her a review, but it was all negative, you gotta add positive like. "Nice try but you could do better" or "this sucks, why even bother!" Those are let downs, it crushes people. and that is what you fail to realize. If you are so confident in your work, post them!

Re: Signature - Posted By sliker (sliker) on 9th Jul 08 at 4:56pm
Thanks Man

Re: Signature - Posted By Alex Bailey (system) on 9th Jul 08 at 5:19pm
 
The signature is really great, and Sven what you fail to realize, is that no one will be as good as you, nor be as bad as you. Everyone has their own style. If you don't like that persons style ok. Sure you gave him or her a review, but it was all negative, you gotta add positive like. "Nice try but you could do better" or "this sucks, why even bother!" Those are let downs, it crushes people. and that is what you fail to realize. If you are so confident in your work, post them!


But why tell people lies when what was said was the truth, and frankly the truth hurts but people gotta get over it

Re: Signature - Posted By Nick (nickb) on 10th Jul 08 at 4:06am
Thats what I meant, Tell the truth, but as well tell them that a reassurance, tell them that they can do better, and next time they may do better.


And since now I see the signature better, it looks like it was made for black backgrounds, as the banner part it's self is rounded off, but the outside image is black, try to make it transparent, or have a drop shadow to make it look like its 3D {Wink}

Re: Signature - Posted By dog199200 (dog199200) on 10th Jul 08 at 6:19am
@sliker: its really, good better then i could do, so just ignor sven, that better then what a lot of people can do, a lot of people can't do anything of that form at all, so for people like sven just ignore then, don't even render that they exist.

@sven: get over yourself, have some respect...

Re: Signature - Posted By slip (slip) on 10th Jul 08 at 7:53am
Let's not have a fight over who's right and who's wrong.

@system: of course the truth is the right thing to say. But it always helps to word a critique prudently. A newcomer might not have any idea who the critique is coming from, and frankly how does it even matter? Encouragement and a subtle push towards how the person may do even better is what is needed. Blatant negation is not.